图书情报知识 ›› 2013, Vol. 0 ›› Issue (6): 114-121.

• 知识、学习与管理 • 上一篇    下一篇

期刊与会议论文的对比分析:以CSSE为例

周颖   

  • 出版日期:2013-11-10 发布日期:2013-11-10

A Comparative Analysis between Periodical Paper and Proceedings Literature:A Case of Computer Science Software Engineering

  • Online:2013-11-10 Published:2013-11-10

摘要:

从论文属性和国别分布两个角度,对CSSE领域在2000~2009年的期刊论文和会议论文展开了对比分析。结果发现:期刊论文与会议论文数量都呈增长趋势,后者增速更快但更不稳定;期刊论文的整体质量要高于会议论文;我国会议论文数量增长速度快于期刊论文,但会议论文质量明显低于其他主要国家。本文研究结果将为加强科研管理提供参考依据。

关键词: 期刊论文, 会议论文, 计量分析, CSSE

Abstract:

This paper made a comparative analysis between periodical paper and proceedings literature in Computer Science Software Engineering field (2000~2009), from two perspectives: trends within (1) paper attributes and (2) individual countries. The results showed that: firstly, the number of periodical paper and proceedings literature both has a growing trend, and the latter grows faster and more unstable. Secondly, the overall quality of periodical papers is better than conference papers. Thirdly, the quality of proceedings literature from China is obviously lower than that of other major countries. The purpose of this study is to provide decisionmaking basis for conference paper evaluation, academic conference management, etc.

Key words: Periodical paper, Proceedings literature, Bibliometric analysis, CSSE