图书情报知识 ›› 2018, Vol. 0 ›› Issue (4): 43-52.doi: 10.13366/j.dik.2018.04.043

• 图书、文献与交流 • 上一篇    下一篇

论文被引频次的影响因素研究——以国内图书情报领域为例

牟象禹,龚凯乐,谢娟,成颖,柯青   

  • 出版日期:2018-07-10 发布日期:2018-07-10

Contributing Factors of Citations: An Empirical Study of Library and Information Science in China

  • Online:2018-07-10 Published:2018-07-10

摘要:

被引频次是定量学术评价的重要指标。目前论文被引频次的分布两极分化严重,大量的被引集中在少量的论文上。针对该现象,本文从整体上对被引频次的影响因素进行探索。研究选取2005—2015年间的18种图书馆学、情报学CSSCI来源期刊论文为数据源,随机抽样600篇作为研究样本,按照论文特征、作者特征、引文特征三大类进行内容分析,共得到41个特征指标。以总被引频次、年均被引频次及下载频次为因变量,其他为自变量,对分类变量进行单因素方差分析,并对连续变量进行相关分析。结果显示文献类型等4个分类变量以及期刊影响因子等20个连续变量与被引存在统计学显著的相关关系。利用主成分分析对20个连续变量进行降维,结果表明作者声望、综合引用情况、作者学术能力、外文引用情况、引文被引频次、合作是影响论文被引的主要因素。

关键词: 被引频次, 影响因素, 图书情报学, 论文特征, 作者特征, 引文特征

Abstract:

The citation frequency is an important indicator of quantitative academic evaluation. Cited qualities of papers seem so polarizing now, which means the majority of academic papers are scarcely cited while a few of others are highly cited. According to that phenomenon, this study comprehensively explores the factors affecting the number of citations. Papers from 18 journals in the field of Library & Information Science and indexed in CSSCI have been chosen as data source, and 600 papers have been selected as samples by random sampling. With content analysis in 3 general categories, named "paperrelated features", "authorrelated features" and "referencerelated features", 41 features have been achieved. This study takes citation counts, annual citation counts as well as download counts as dependent variables and others as independent variables. Oneway ANOVA is performed on the categorical variables, and correlation analysis is performed on the continuous variables. It has been found out that 4 categorical variables, such as literature type, and 20 continuous variables, such as journal influence factors, are significantly correlated with citation counts. By using principal component analysis to reduce the continuous variables, results show that authors' reputation, profile of references, authors' academic performance, citation of foreignlanguage literatures, citation counts of references and cooperation are the main factors that influence citations.

Key words: Citation frequency, Impact factor, Library &, information science, Paper-related features, Author-related features, Reference-related features